Islamic Insights | Inspired by the Holy Quran and AhlulBayt | Publication of The Awaited One Foundation

AhlulBayt Academy


Last update05:00:00 AM GMT

Back Insights Features Health Why Healthcare Reform Could Leave Us All Worse Off

Why Healthcare Reform Could Leave Us All Worse Off

  • PDF

Protesters demand more equal healthcare reform.New America Media – The healthcare reform bills being debated in Congress threaten to shut out millions of immigrants. But Congress' exclusionary policies toward immigrants will not simply leave immigrants worse off. They will inevitably jeopardize the nation's economy and the health of all of us.

President Obama has prioritized healthcare reform to ensure that millions of Americans have a fair, affordable, and efficient healthcare system. For immigrants, this vision is far from a reality. First, the current healthcare reform bill treats legal immigrants unfairly. Individuals who have waited years to come to the United States will be required to wait years in order to obtain affordable healthcare. 

Immigrants are generally younger and healthier than the U.S. population at large. However, no one is immune to falling ill or having an accident. The current healthcare bill would require recently arrived, legal immigrants to wait five years to obtain the only option for affordable healthcare coverage, Medicaid. While low-income citizens will have access to Medicaid, the most vulnerable among us will continue to wait for affordable healthcare despite the fact that they pay taxes for the very programs from which they are excluded. There is no sound reason for Congress to discriminate against these individuals and prevent them from receiving basic medical care.

Congress and the White House also took an unprecedented step to prohibit individuals from buying – with their own hard-earned money – an American good that could help their families. The Senate version of the healthcare bill forbids undocumented immigrants from purchasing private insurance at full cost in the newly created insurance marketplaces. As a result, undocumented immigrants as well as their family members, who are often U.S. citizens or legal immigrants, will likely remain uninsured and will be forced to seek care in the emergency room.

The costs of providing healthcare for undocumented immigrants will not disappear after passing healthcare reform. It is unlikely that millions of immigrants, whose contributions keep up our standard of living and our economy functioning, will be deported. Instead, the cost of care will become the financial responsibility of the patient, the provider, the local and state governments, and every single taxpayer. Moreover, in order to exclude a few, there will be additional forms, documents, and bureaucrats that the rest of us will be subjected to. Buying the mandated health insurance could feel like a trip to the Department of Motor Vehicles. Taxpayers will have to pay millions for this additional red tape and delay, all to keep a few people from buying health insurance with their own money.

Providers, employers, consumers, religious leaders, and state and local governments recognize that these policies are short-sighted and will cost all of us more in the long-run. Policies that attempt to exclude and ostracize immigrants also disproportionately harm all communities of color and immigrant-rich states like California and New York, further widening existing inequities in our nation. Yet because immigrants live in all 50 states, the intended and unintended consequences and costs of these restrictions will be far-reaching.

Ending discriminatory and exclusionary policies in this final round of negotiations is not only a matter of fundamental fairness and sound economics. It is required in order to not leave all of us worse off. Congress has a short window of opportunity to remove the restrictions on legal and undocumented immigrants in the healthcare reform bill. Doing so will not jeopardize the passage of the bill. Failing to doing so, however, will leave all of us, immigrant or not, worse off and wondering what happened to the promise of healthcare reform.

Author of this article: Sonal Ambegaokar
Interesting Reading