Islamic Insights | Inspired by the Holy Quran and AhlulBayt | Publication of The Awaited One Foundation

AhlulBayt Academy

Thu05172012

Last update11:22:56 AM GMT

Back Insights Features Fashion Debasing the Hijab

Debasing the Hijab

  • PDF

Flashy modesty?

The effect and prominence of advertisements today have driven society from a functioning level of critical thinking into a group of consumers with practically no objectivity, bought easily into the notions of propaganda-laced media. A simple television advertisement can cause a person to feel utterly paranoid and self-conscious about their appearance, forcing them to spend ridiculous amounts on products that promise beauty and hence happiness. This effect is not only restricted to beauty and clothing products, but rather seeps through all that consumers hold in high regard. The phenomenon has subsequently led to the commercialization of religious holidays (with Christmas today being reduced to a mere title with little meaning), and in recent years has also established influence in the Muslim world, geared particularly towards females who wear the Hijab.

Amongst the numerous reasons as to why Muslim women choose to wear it, the Hijab is a symbolic representation of their rejection of being slaves to the world of fashion. Yet today, dozens if not hundreds of Hijab fashion websites touting the latest Hijab trends, fashion shops made solely for Hijabi females and general immodest clothing considered suitable for Muslim women have all attempted to slowly transform the Hijab into a fashion symbol of sorts. The concept of modesty in Islam is well and truly being confused with the common-day image of the Hijab. It seems to be forgotten that it was through Islam's high regard for modesty that the Hijab returned power to women following centuries of injustice and inequity, by allowing the character of a female to dictate her status, success and progress rather than her physical appearance.

In an increasingly materialistic society that functions only through individuals spending beyond their capacities, the inadequacies of the old system rejected by Islam and its oppressive status quo is being projected on Muslim women through the notion of "fashion Hijab" and the-hip-young-Muslimah-who-purchases-only-designer-wear. Where exactly does this contradiction manifest itself? It requires us to realize that in a society where females are directly and indirectly taught to limit their intellectual and social input, the concepts of Hijab and modesty are huge roadblocks. Consider that the only form of media which young females are overwhelmingly represented in is magazines, in which approximately 70 per cent of the editorial content focus on beauty and fashion while roughly 12 per cent cover topics such as school or careers.

Unfortunately, many modern Muslim women have – consciously or not – fallen short of the high rank God has afforded to them by forsaking His decree and instead chasing after the latest fashion trends. There is a large and growing market for Western-inspired clothing with immodest fabrics, colors and cuts being passed off as "Hijab fashion" today. While there are those who like to romanticize and claim that at last the Hijab is becoming hip, what we are actually witnessing instead is the deliberate watering down of God's directive on the Hijab. For when we make attempts to fuse modesty with fashion shows and name brands, we effectively remove its significance and allow it to become open to rapidly deteriorating interpretation. This is not to suggest Muslim women should dress in an unpolished and undignified manner as a means of obtaining self-ascribed asceticism. However, the purpose of Hijab is certainly defeated if it becomes primarily centered on the value of the clothing worn.

While promoting a very superficial understanding of the Islamic dress code, the recent upsurge in stores, high fashion designers and brands marketing flashy Hijab styles is continuously attracting and luring many young Muslim women today. There are countless Facebook websites with thousands of Muslim women supporting stores that are destroying the very essence of the Hijab. Eager to show the world how young Muslim women in the West are redefining the Hijab, media outlets endlessly highlight the arrival of the "high fashion Hijab" trend. More disturbing than this is the pride that Hijab-clad women are taking in these brands, which are fundamentally destroying their identity through debasing and devaluing the modest dress code. It serves a great purpose to remind ourselves that the Hijab is not simply a stylish accessory, but a way of life and character. It is for women not to be judged by their clothing size, brand of clothing, cosmetics or material possessions, but rather by spiritual submission and achievements.

Author of this article: Huda Jawad
Interesting Reading

Comments  

 
+4 # Layla 2010-09-20 12:06
I sincerely disagree. If a Muslim woman is modest and wishes to dress fashionably while doing this, why not? What rule in the Quran dictates what designer a woman can and cannot wear? I'm sure you've seen thobes created by Louis Vuittton or Dior yet men wearing fashion trends remains unaddressed. If anything, I feel doing such helps the view of Islam in the West because people will be less likely to see us (Muslim women) as oppressed and thus in kind less likely to see our religion as oppressive towards women. You attract more flies with honey as the saying goes. If there is a wish to attract more people to Islam in a positive way, I believe fashion is a good start.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+8 # Marzia 2010-09-20 13:57
@ Laila. one of the main purposes of Hijab is modesty. Wearing fashionable clothes that will catch the attention and inspire other females is okay but what if it attracts the attention of a male? Western society has never shown Muslims in the positive light rather negative all along. One shouldn't care what others think whether our religion seems oppressed to them or not. We as Muslims know our religion is not oppressing us into wearing the Hijab. It requires women to wear Hijab, however it's a woman's choice if she chooses to wear it or not.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # dunya 2010-09-20 16:54
i agree with both of you :)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+6 # Anni shah 2010-09-22 08:15
sister marzia... i agreee but the last sentence you said : 'It requires woman to wear hijab, however its a woman's choice if she chooses to wear it or not'.... :o sister marzia hijab is Obligatory i.e. it is wajib..its not 'womans choice'..
If there were a choice then i guess there would be a minority of muslim woman observing hijab, but no - allah has made it wajib ..so it is no bodys choice, exctly we shouldnt look at it like that, > allah has made it wajib so we can protect oursleves.. isnt that jus beautifull...subhanaallah
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Nawal Alsaeed 2010-09-20 14:06
"Unfortunately, many modern Muslim women have – consciously or not – fallen short of the high rank God has afforded to them by forsaking His decree and instead chasing after the latest fashion trends." I have caused myself to "forsake His decree" by chasing after the latest fashion trends? "Hijab is a symbolic representation of the rejection to the world of fashion," SAYS WHO and SINCE WHEN?

Hijab is a symbolic representation of modesty and purity. Hijab in its self is a label to the world that "I AM A MUSLIM WOMAN." It is a label to the West, East, North and South. Why can't I wear my Burberry or my LV scarf to represent my Hijab. Why can't I wear my skinny jeans with a sweater dress and platform ankle boots? Why can a Muslim doctor drive a Mercedes Benz?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # FatimaZahra 2010-09-21 11:31
@Nawal: I don't think there is a mandate in Islam that says you can or cannot drive a Mercedes Benz or dress in (modest) designer clothing. I think what Huda Jawad is trying to get at here is also the idea of humility. What's better in the eyes of Allah (SWT)--that I drive a Benz (because I can afford it) or if I drive a more moderately-priced car and spend that extra money on purchasing another car for a needy family? The same can also be said for the spendy designer clothing--I can purchase a $300 Dior tunic or I can purchase a much more moderately priced outfit and spend that extra cash on someone who truly needs it. It gets at that fine line between wants vs. needs...

(Don't get me wrong though... I'm just as tempted to purchase that Benz or the Dior dress as the next person. But I think we mustn't loose sight of our ultimate goal--al-Akhirah--with such worldly goods.)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # AB 2010-12-22 15:54
Actually Hijab is a protection for us from the many sexual encounters a woman can experience. The way a Muslimah should dress does not include any revealing or sheer clothing, or even imitating the dress of men. Modesty and purity is the characters that follow along with the Hijab. But like you I didn't realize this until someone told this to me. It was subconsciously in the back of my mind, so when I did see for myself I realized it is a dress of modesty as opposed to wearing clothing that seem to be partial dress.
Allaah says (interpretation of the meaning):
“And tell the believing women to lower their gaze (from looking at forbidden things), and protect their private parts (from illegal sexual acts) and not to show off their adornment except only that which is apparent (like both eyes for necessity to see the way, or outer palms of hands or one eye or dress like veil, gloves, headcover, apron), and to draw their veils all over Juyoobihinna (i.e. their bodies, faces, necks and bosoms) and not to reveal their adornment except to their husbands, or their fathers, or their husband’s fathers, or their sons, or their husband’s sons, or their brothers or their brother’s sons, or their sister’s sons, or their (Muslim) women (i.e. their sisters in Islam), or the (female) slaves whom their right hands possess, or old male servants who lack vigour, or small children who have no sense of feminine sex. And let them not stamp their feet so as to reveal what they hide of their adornment. And all of you beg Allaah to forgive you all, O believers, that you may be successful”
[al-Noor 24:31]
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+5 # Nawal Alsaeed 2010-09-20 14:10
Yes, the purpose of hijab is certainly defeated if it becomes primarily centered on the value of the clothing worn...BUT there is a runt in every litter and a misconception of every ideology. There are the liberals, the moderates, the conservatives and the extremist in every cultural, religious, and social belief and there are most definitely the misrepresentations of being modestly fashionable.

This article is much too general and there needs to be a clarification as to who this article is targeting. She speaks of the self-ascribed asceticism but what if we use latest fashion trends in doing so? There is always going to be someone to take something out of context, and yes, there are muslim woman who have taken advantage of latest fashion trends and marked them as Hijab friends but I can tell you, I am fashionable and very modestly dressed.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+9 # masooma 2010-09-20 16:19
There are a few fundamental issues with the fashion industry and following fashion trends that are concerning.

One, they feed the culture of consumerism and materialism by encouraging women to buy things they don't need and by trying to dictate to them what they should want by saying that something is "in" now, rather than having them use their own minds.

Two, by assigning value to labels and name-brands, women are encouraged to spend money at amounts way out of line with the true material value of the object, but rather instead on maintaining a materialist-determined, consumer-driven image that has absolutely no Islamic worth at all.

So when you want to wear something, as yourself - what is the purpose? Who are you trying to please or impress? Men? Yourself? Fashionistas? Allah swt?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # FatimaZahra 2010-09-21 11:32
Well said!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # Layla 2010-09-20 17:26
What if you're a seamstress and you create an exact replication of a designer abaya for a lot less? Is this still considered harmful? What if Muslim women would like to wear something beautiful, I don't know, for the sake of wearing a piece of art that was painstakingly made. If what you said about wearing nice things, why does everyone dress up for Eid? It should follow that no oneshould dress up for anything ever, for who would they be trying to impress? The argument is not plausible. I also disagree that we shouldn't care what other people think. It's because of this selfish lack of care that so many people misunderstand the Muslim religion.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+3 # Layla 2010-09-20 17:27
Again, we're not addressing men either. Who are they trying to impress with their fancy cars and dress? I don't think it's Allah (swt). It should not be so important to dedicate so much time on something trivial. Allah (swt) is the only judge we should be worried about, and if we are wearing our hijab modestly and know our own intentions, then the gossip and condemnation needs to stop.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # Daniell 2010-09-20 18:49
I agree with masooma. Frankly, your a stupid man/woman for spending money on designer items that dont retain their value as time goes on. For every 1500 dollar bag you carry that has your credit cards in it, is a bag that could of fed 3 orphans for a full year. This is a sickness going on in the Muslim communities. People with cars they cant afford, student loans they havent paid off, homes they dont own and counter tops that need to be replaced come before any designer belt gets to wrap your waist.

And i dont care if ive offended any of you. I have confidence that no prophet would have had a Mont blac pen in his pocket.

As for hijabis. You can wear what you want so long as its modest. You can be a fashionable as you want. Just please be SMART in terms of the monetary blessings Allah swt gives you. Does Jimmy cho REALLY made you THAT happy?

If so, you've got issues.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+1 # FatimaZahra 2010-09-21 11:34
@Daniell. I agree with you but you come across a bit harsh... :sad:

I don't think our Prophet would be caught with a Mont Blac pen in pocket or even driving in a Benz (though he probably could have afforded the "cadillac" of all camels back then with Hazrat Khadjijah's wealth)...
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Anni shah 2010-09-22 08:20
i totally agrreee with u sis!!
u go girl!!

LOL
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # also known as. 2010-09-23 13:52
I have confidence that no prophet would think offending others is something that doesn't matter. :o

By the way, your argument is flawed in some ways -- neither is having a valuable item sinful nor is wanting it. If it was an issue, we would not see Prophet Sulaiman owning so much. The issue is when our things begin to own us, instead of us owning them.

In any case, we should read a bit more about Islam and live a little. We should enjoy life, but not let it fool us as the end goal. Also, we should make sure that what we find enjoyable is what Allah says is best, not what people desire. I have no problem with fashion, but when it begins to include form fitting sweaters and skinny jeans, that is a problem.

Think about it.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # saki 2010-09-22 16:49
totally disagree with this article, instead of promoting and encouragin women to so hijab, its actually making it harder for the women who do wear hijab, bringing them to a harsher colder standard.if someone can be modest and stylish at the same time, ofcourse the style being with the laws of modesty islam requires....then theres nothing wrong with it, we r not amish
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # RE: saki 2010-09-22 19:19
"the style being with the laws of modesty islam requires"

How would you define the laws of modesty that Islam requires?
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+1 # saki 2010-09-22 21:37
from what i understand the islamic law to be--first and fore most --no hair, ears, neck showing, shirt should be long sleeves and flowy--not tight so u can see the chest-size (my apolgizes for being blunt) not those perfect fit tees and not see thru, and u cannot see the shape of the body, which means none of those tight belts, or skinny jeans, or pencil thin skirts) feet should be covered, no strappy sandals, you should be clean and fresh, thus deoderant and light bod spray or perfume, not those heavy drenched ones where everyone around u can smell u, light makeup to hide small imperfections that bother u, cause islam wants to attract people and islam wants cleaniness, and islam wants u to learn about the latest science and tech, and medicine, so islam wants to be fwd in everything except style?
cont
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # saki 2010-09-22 21:48
cont
as u can see, i have so many, too many restrictions on what i can wear, so after i pay off my khums, and do all my wajibat w/my paycheck, why i cant buy a lv handbag, blahnik flats, chanel necklace, a burberry scarf? or why cant i wear a outfit i brought from the mall, that hides my figure, do i have to wear a handmade shalwar khameez just cause i want to observe hijab? its bad enough i have to put up with peoples stares and snide comments, but according to the artical i should be wearing a garbage bag. high fashion hijab, i welcome u with open arms,
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # saki 2010-09-22 21:54
and i love jimmy choo shoes, obviousaly the quality and the feel u get f when u wear high end accesorries is exhilierating. although since i wear"hijab" with my lv bag, i know most people think its s a knock off, but atleast I know the truth donate too all shia based charities,
actually thank u, for making me write thiese comments , im def gonna do a shukrana namaz for that god has given me :lol:
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+6 # masooma 2010-09-23 07:11
I think many people reading this article seem to be jumping to the defensive and and making conclusions not necessarily supported by the article or even directly contradicted by it in some cases. Don't read between the lines, read the lines.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # RainMaker 2010-09-23 09:11
Many Prophets came without a book, but no book came without a Prophet..why..? We needed role models and somebody to explain the book to us. When it comes to the role model of Hijab the first person who comes to mind is the one dearest to the Prophet... Fatima (as). Who could unerstand the concept of Hijab better than the daughter of the Prophet(SAW). When it comes to spending money on luxury items there is a limit . Daniell is right about spending money wisely even for hijab. Wearing the Hijab means that you are following that which is Allah has advised you to do. So when you wear extra expensive hijab you do follow what Allah has said about the hijab but on the other hand you are not thinking about how Islam has told us to spend our wealth.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-2 # Fatimah12346 2010-09-23 14:39
Imam Jaffar-as-Saddiq was well known for dressing in the nicest of designs and materials.

Everything has a time and a place. Wearing Louis Vitton in a poor Congo neighborhood would be offensive, but wearing Louis Vitton in Paris is standard and acceptable.

(It might just be possible to buy a $2,000 bag AND AND help feed a poor family with $2,000. You can do both you know, when you got the money.)

The point is to look appropriate and relevant in the setting you are in, without compromising the physical modesty required. Hejab should be appealing.

And those that argue that women who wear designer clothing as hejab attract attention, the fact is that different men are attracted to different features - it all depends on their standard. Some men in Saudi Arabia will stalk and stare down a women draped head to toe in black, because they think he is sexy and beautiful - that's their standard. Perhaps the same is not attractive at all to a western man.

Point being, you can't please all of the people all of the time. Women who dress up, 9 times out of 10 do so for themselves first, and for other women second. Most women just enjoy the art of fashion. It's more practical than buying housewares and paintings - which as a matter of fact I don't hear too many people complaining about, but maybe - just maybe - those items are more wasteful than clothing.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Fatimah12346 2010-09-23 14:41
The other point I wanted to make is those who claim that a $1,000 bag or other item is just plain over priced and is just as good as a $10 bag has basically no idea what it takes to make apparel and accessories and is not versed in business and pricing. Some items are indeed overpriced, but as it turns out, its usually your $40 made in Chin cheap shoes that are overpriced, instead of the $300 made in Italy shoes.

You might think that buying Cheap and Inexpensive stuff is saving you money, but in the end we all pay a much bigger social price - especially for things like harsh working conditions that the makers of those items suffer from, and the low pay that they receive.

IF you don't believe, just check out the Financial Reports of companies like Walmart, and check their margins and profitability against your Louis Vittons.
LV employees don't complain of poor working conditions or low wages, but makers of products that get sold in Walmart do.

Seriously, just try to think a little beyond your own pocket book for a change.


Finally, someone said something about resale value. The $2,000 bag obviously has a much higher resale value than the $10 walmart bag. In fact, most of the time you can sell the bag for close to the price you purchased it for - extending the value of the item for years and years, and even generations. And because many of these expensive bags are so well crafted, they do in fact withstand the test of time. Unlike the Walmart bag, which needs prompt replacing after a few months of use.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Fatimah12346 2010-09-23 14:48
So let's be clear, there's two issues here, which are quite separate from each other.

1. which is Wasteful spending on trendy Fast Fashion junk, whether its expensive or cheap, simply for the pleasure of owning and showing off.

2. is investing in well-crafted fashion apparel and accessories, that have longer life and better craftsmanship (by professionals of the trade) than cheap junk. And paying the true price for the cost of producing those items and the smaller quantities they are available in (since they are not produced in the same mass as your cheaper junk - which are so cheap because of economies of scale, cheap materials and low wages).

Let's not mistake them as they are not one and the same to be lumped together and dismissed as merely "fashion" and "trend" or "overpriced" shopping behaviors.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # Fatimah12346 2010-09-23 14:50
Final point, if you want to support poor families, don't buy overly cheap plastic junk from walmart, or cheap clothing and accessories. That would help poor people a lot! Pay for the real cost instead, and buy local or professionally produced (yes, it will be more expensive)!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # Reader 2010-09-23 15:25
Friends, read the article, then comment. The comments being made are not an accurate reflection of the article.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # CaliforniaSister 2010-09-24 11:59
Salaam Aleykium! Thank you sister Huda for the inspriring article, and the slap of truth. We first need to operationalize the word "Fashion". The latest materials/colors does not necessairly mean that one is not following the decree of God. Now the problem with Hijab and I have had opinions from Ulema stating that what constitutes the Modest dress, is that you are not attracting too much attention to yourself.
Now we must think of context. Wearing my California hijabi outfit in Qom, Iran, where most people where abaya, I might stand out like a sore thumb. Therefore as sisters we have to observe our surroundings and wear appropriate modest clothing while at the same time not asking for attention. My local Imam suggest that pastel colors are better for modest women to wear then bright colors that bring attention like purple/white mix or pink/green mix. This article is forcing hijabi women to think really hard about what they are wearing and whether or not they are enforcing the modest that our Prophets peace be onto them, would be proud of.
The outburst of the latest glam fashions has Muslim women dressing just like the western women with a head scarf. You can see how skinny jeans dont fit the modest model. And this is the precise issue one should look at when they are shopping for clothes.
1.) Am I trying to be as attractive as britney spears and beyonce?
2.) Am I trying to get married over night?
I joke a lot, but in all seriousness what we wear really tells someone what we adhere too, if our fashion stands out more then our modesty then we did not do a very good job of picking our outfit.

Buying the latest fashion clothes is fine, the question is what that piece represents and how it looks upon the greater society you are wearing it in.

8) 8) 8) 8) 8) 8)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # sayka 2010-09-27 01:08
well i think Allah has gifted women with hijab.its wajib and all muslim women should accept this gift as it is wajib and should not bother about others,what they think about our looks..hijab definitely is our identity that differentiates a muslim from non muslim.it protects us from bad eyes n bad looks.such a lovely gift given by our God,respect it...
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+1 # Zainab 2010-09-27 23:59
Thanks for finally writing the truth about hijab. The first time I saw Islamic Insights, it held an article on hijab and how to fashionize it. I was appalled. The slightest thing a woman wears which could attract men is haram--that means even a beautiful diamond wedding ring or khohl under the eyes (in the eyes is medicinal, allowed and doesn't appear to be an outward beauty. Our ulema have said keep thing simple. Islam isn't about wearing beautiful clothing for others--save that for the husband. It's about not attracting those who are not mehram. On ulema told us that today, women are like women outside and like men inside. Think about it--and think about the growing divorce rate as well.
The first thing I do when buying clothing is to ask my husband whether or not it's attractive to him (physically). I've even been given lacy material for an abiya--he said it was sexy. So sisters--ask your fathers, brothers or husbands what they think. The whole purpose of hijab is to keep women from the evil intentions and looks of men--not to add to the problem. I tell my daughter--if the words chic or fashion are in the hijab description--stay away from it! Dearborn sisters are getting a reputation for the way they wear hijab. And no amount of argument is going to solve the problem until they fix the hijab themselves. Great article!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+4 # also known as . 2010-10-01 18:09
Actually you're wrong. A ring which is considered normal, like a diamond ring, is halal according to our ulema. Also, kohl is allowed, according to our ulema. The only exception is if these become a means of attracting others. So the default position is that these things are allowed, not banned. You shouldn't use the crazy extreme hijab styles in some places as reason to make what is halal things haraam for everywhere else. This is why I'm glad Islamic Insights ran those style watch articles. Alas, those days seem long gone. At least this week's article about the woman embracing hijab was well done and honest, not another rant.

Secondly, Islam IS about beauty and dressing nicely. We have so many traditions and verses from the Quran about the importance of wearing nice dress. Furthermore, if beauty was a bad thing then Allah would not have created Yusuf (as) or other prophets to be so handsome. What Islam is NOT for is attracting sexual attention. But it is possible for some clothes to be beautiful without attracting such attention. Not every kind of beauty is sexual, and not every sexual thing is beautiful. This is clear.

Finally, you are wrong about saying "the whole purpose of hijab is to keep women from the evil intentions and looks of men". Hijab is not just about women, it is about protecting men too. Furthermore, men have the responsibility of casting down their glance. It is completely ridiculous that you put all the pressure on women. In some very strict Muslim countries women where full hijab and niqab even, but they are still harassed sometimes.

You shouldn't use preventing bad looks from the most depraved, sick parts of society as the litmus test for what is good hijab. We need to fix men too, not just put all the pressure on women.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # nsdAm 2010-10-02 02:22
And by the way, while we're talking about prophet Yusuf, he received plenty of sexual attention from the women, but he did not respond to their fantasies. So obviously it is possible to look good and for the blame to be on the lustful party, not the person with the nice appearance. The same can be said about women who where nice non-sexual clothing -- they should not be blamed for every bad sort of glance that comes their way. Men are responsible too!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Layla 2010-09-30 23:19
I don't understand the "wasteful spending" argument. Allah truly knows best, but if a sister is wealthy and pays her zakat, sadaqa, gives charity, volunteers, invests, etc. Why in the world can she not buy, say a fancy designer abaya? What right do we have to tell people where, when and how to spend their money...do I hear communist bells ringing? Designers pay people money to create their designs. Poor people who need jobs are supported by this money, just as local stores are supported. Although in this case, they are probably being paid better than those working for walmart ;-) There's nothing unislamic about an abaya either, so you can't use the "modesty" argument either. If you can't afford it, don't buy it, if you can (all Islamic rules being followed) I say go for it!
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
+2 # Hana 2011-03-01 14:08
I agree with bits and pieces of all of these comments.
I am a British revert, and I see a HUGE part of my jihad being projecting a positive image of Islam to people who know nothing about it. In the West, Muslim women are so often seen as oppressed.....with no life or character. I want to challenge this. So yes, I like to dress in a stylish way, because I would want non-Muslim women to say 'Oh, she looks really cute', or 'I like her headscarf like that'. And ok, maybe the odd guy will look.....but if I guy is gonna look, he will do so whatever you're wearing...and as long as you've covered the principles of modest dress, then the accountability is on him. I think it IS possible to be stylish whilst maintaining modesty. I DO agree however, that the number of sites geered towards hijabi fashion is getting a little out of hand, as many of these have pics posted up of sisters posing in a way which represents the glossy magazine spreads (and we should not imitate the disbelievers). Also, I don't agree with hijab styles where earrings are shown, or over-the-top adornments such as flowers and jewels are used. We are given instructions on dress with context in mind. So, it draws more attention to me if, for example, i go out in black abaya and hijab in my little rural community. So I wear 'regular' clothes to blend in with the other young girls. However, if I were to go to a country where these regular clothes made me stick out like a sore thumb....then I'd opt for abaya.

In my humble opinion, when you look at yourself in the mirror before you walk out of the door....you know in your heart whether you are pleasing Allah. Anthing that makes you feel uncomfortable is not right, and should be abandoned.

Fanastic and important topic to bring up. Jazak Allah khair sisters.
May Allah have mercy on us and forgive us for our shortcomings.

Hana (hanamuslimah.wordpress.com)
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # Altaf 2011-06-24 10:26
I APPRECIATE THIS ARTICLE AND OPEN VALUABLE DISCUSSIONS AND DIFFERENT IDEAS,as commented by one of our sisters...''So when you want to wear something, ask yourself - what is the purpose? Who are you trying to please or impress? Men? Yourself? Fashionistas? Allah swt?''
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # hello 2012-01-02 01:10
read this article about the muslims in dubai and how they treat their workers and maids, is this islamic? how can we stop this??

independent.co.uk/.../...
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
-2 # lola 2012-01-02 17:04
She looks great, all people are beautiful men and women, why do the Muslim -Islamic- Arabic men discriminate against their women? because Mohummad told them to.
Mohummad was an ignorant old man, who created a law for women to cover themselves. and his idiot followers did it without question.
Wearing the Hijab in your own home is fine, just don't thrust it upon everyone else.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 
 
0 # zeinab 2012-01-19 10:55
Quoting lola:
She looks great, all people are beautiful men and women, why do the Muslim -Islamic- Arabic men discriminate against their women? because Mohummad told them to.
Mohummad was an ignorant old man, who created a law for women to cover themselves. and his idiot followers did it without question.
Wearing the Hijab in your own home is fine, just don't thrust it upon everyone else.








why r u on this site? are you one of the ignorant, stubborn disbelivers that Allah mentions in the quran?
Prophet Muhammed ( peace be uopn him) did not tell anyone to dicriminate there woman.
also do not dare say that prophet muhammed was ignorant. the only one ignorant is you who propbably knows nothing about islam, and to prove that you know nothing about islam you said prohet muhammed created a law for woman to wear the hijab. Untrue Allah created this rule of wearing the hijab.therefore us "IDIOTS" have not been ignorant like others and obey Allah.
Reply | Reply with quote | Quote
 

Add comment

Islamic Insights does not necessarily endorse any comments published by our web users unless otherwise noted. Posting links to other websites will be allowed as long as it pertains to the discussion. Spamming the comments page with articles and other links may get you banned. By submitting your comments, you acknowledge our right, at our sole discretion, to change, modify, add, or delete your comments and portions of these Terms of Use at any time without further notice.

Security code
Refresh